Meal Replacement for Weight Loss: Do They Work? Will You Regain Weight?

Do meal replacements actually work for weight loss? These days, there are all kinds of meal replacement options — shakes, grain-based meals, nutritional powders — but can simply relying on these help you slim down effortlessly? Are you more likely to regain weight after using meal replacements? Does healthy weight loss mean eating only veggies at every meal? If you're curious about how to lose weight the healthy way, and wondering whether meal replacements are reliable, take note of the following!

1

What Are Meal Replacements? Understanding Meal Replacements and How They Help You Lose Weight

For busy Hongkongers, using meal replacements for weight loss can be incredibly convenient — it saves time and effort spent preparing healthy meals, which is why many beauty gurus often recommend them.

But what exactly are meal replacements, and how do they differ from typical diet meals? As the name suggests, meal replacements are foods intended to take the place of regular meals. The idea behind using them for weight loss is simple: by consuming low-calorie alternatives, your daily caloric intake decreases. When your intake is less than the energy your body uses, weight loss occurs. There are many types of meal replacement products on the market — shakes, powders, soups, and more.

Why Can Meal Replacements Substitute for Regular Meals?

An average adult woman needs about 1,400 calories a day. Lunch and dinner typically make up about 480 calories each. A single meal replacement, however, usually contains just 200–300 calories — meaning you could cut about 230 calories per meal by using a replacement instead.

Meal replacement products must follow strict regulations regarding their ingredients. Regions like Taiwan, Europe, and Australia have guidelines outlining their composition. A proper meal replacement must contain carbs, protein (mainly from milk or soy, but no more than half the total content), and less than 30% fat. It should also provide about 30% of your daily vitamin and mineral requirements. Some products even include added fiber or sugar substitutes — not only to help with constipation, but also to make the meal more palatable.

Types of Meal Replacement Products Available

The market offers a wide range of meal replacement products, generally categorized into three groups: food, drinks, and snacks.

• Food-based replacements include items like veggie porridge, brown rice, and konjac noodles — usually ready to eat after heating.
• Drink-based replacements — such as shakes, soups, and juices — are more popular. They come in either ready-to-drink vacuum packs or as powders to be mixed with water.
• Snack-based meal replacements are even more varied, including low-calorie cookies, energy bars, dried fruit and nut bars, and jellies — often sold in eye-catching packaging to attract consumers.

2

How to Use Meal Replacements for Weight Loss? Here’s the Best Meal Replacement Schedule!

If you want to lose weight in a healthy way using meal replacements, it’s best to consult a doctor or registered dietitian before you begin. Depending on your weight loss goals and lifestyle, you can then choose how to incorporate meal replacements into your routine. For instance, if your BMI is over 40, it’s important to ensure your daily intake doesn’t fall below 1,200 calories when starting out. This helps your body gradually adjust and prevents health issues.

There are two main methods of using meal replacements for weight loss:

• Total meal replacement: You consume only meal replacement products for all three meals during a specific period.
• Partial meal replacement: You substitute one or two meals per day with meal replacements. If you choose this option, make sure your non-replacement meals still follow healthy eating guidelines.

If you're only replacing one meal, it's best to choose dinner, since it's typically recommended to consume fewer calories in the evening.

Meal Replacement Schedule for Weight Loss

Nutritionists advise setting a specific timeframe for using meal replacements and regularly tracking your progress. A typical plan lasts 8 to 12 weeks. Studies have shown that meal replacements can be quite effective over 6 to 12 months, but long-term results may vary.

Important Things to Note

For meal replacements to be truly effective, you must also make positive lifestyle and dietary changes and incorporate regular exercise. Nutritionists emphasize that combining meal replacements with exercise and a healthy diet is essential to achieving lasting weight loss and minimizing the risk of regaining the weight.

One study from 2019 found that using total meal replacement alongside exercise for a set period helped participants lose an average of 9kg. Even after returning to regular meals, the weight loss was maintained for a year — showing that it can be a stable and ideal approach if done properly.

3

Why Is Weight Regain So Common with Meal Replacement Diets? Understanding the Rebound Effect

Many people are skeptical about whether meal replacements truly work for weight loss — it seems too easy to be effective. And indeed, many users have found that their weight tends to rebound after using meal replacement diets. Here are a few common reasons why:

Reason #1: Developing Dependence on Meal Replacements

If you rely too heavily on the idea of “losing weight the lazy way” and only eat meal replacements without incorporating exercise, your metabolism may slow down over time. This lowers your basal metabolic rate (BMR) and causes your body to go into energy conservation mode — converting any incoming food into fat to store for later. So once you stop using meal replacements and return to regular meals, your weight can quickly rebound.

Reason #2: Hard to Stick With Long-Term

Meal replacements tend to have bland flavors and limited variety, making them difficult to stick with for extended periods. If you suppress your cravings for too long, you may end up bingeing later, causing your weight to rebound. Also, since meal replacements are usually only meant to replace one meal per day, they don’t provide the same level of nutrition or satiety as regular meals. This can increase hunger and lead to overeating during your other meals — especially if you replace too many meals with low-calorie alternatives. Another challenge is the cost — high-quality meal replacement products can be expensive, and not everyone can afford them over several months.

Reason #3: Falling into the Snack Trap

There’s a wide variety of snack-type meal replacements on the market, including treats that look like indulgent desserts. Although they typically have fewer calories than regular snacks, it's easy to overeat them under the assumption that they’re “healthier.” This can lead to excess calorie intake, slowing your weight loss progress or even causing weight gain. To stay on track, it's important not to let your guard down just because something is labeled as a meal replacement.

4

The 5 Shocking Side Effects of Meal Replacement Diets! Side Effects of Meal Replacement Diets

Aside from the potential for weight regain, meal replacement diets may also come with a range of side effects. Those who are trying to lose weight need to be aware of these potential issues.

Side Effect 1: Easily Fatigued

Meal replacements often lack balanced nutrition, and if your body isn't getting enough carbohydrates, you may feel tired, have difficulty concentrating, and experience memory loss. Since meal replacements may not provide sufficient satiety, prolonged periods of semi-hunger can also negatively affect sleep quality, leaving you feeling even more fatigued.

Side Effect 2: Skin Aging

Meal replacements typically do not contain the antioxidants found in natural foods, and they often have lower protein content. Protein is important for maintaining skin elasticity, and insufficient protein intake over time can cause your body to break down muscle protein to meet its needs. This can lead to premature skin aging compared to a normal, balanced diet.

Side Effect 3: Some Meal Replacements May Cause Fatty Liver

Some fruit-based meal replacements are high in sugar. If consumed daily or used to replace regular meals, this can lead to excessive sugar intake. After metabolizing the sugar, some of it will be stored as triglycerides in the body. If too much accumulates, this can develop into fatty liver.

Side Effect 4: Menstrual Irregularities

A meal replacement diet is essentially a form of calorie restriction, and when the body’s intake of protein and other nutrients is insufficient, it can cause the pituitary gland to function poorly. This reduces the secretion of gonadotropins, which in turn affects the function of reproductive organs like the ovaries. As a result, women on meal replacement diets may experience menstrual irregularities, such as shorter cycles, irregular periods, or even the absence of menstruation.

Side Effect 5: Constipation

During a meal replacement diet, because of reduced food intake and overall energy intake, the body's organ functions may slow down, including the digestive system. The intestines may slow their peristalsis, leading to constipation. Additionally, if the diet is completely fat-free, the intestines may lack lubrication, making it harder to pass stools.

Nutritionists Say: Meal Replacement Diets Could Affect Your Health! Nutritionists' View on Meal Replacement Diets

Nutritionists may recommend meal replacements for some people, but when using meal replacements for weight loss, it’s important to stay hydrated. You should aim to drink at least 2,000 milliliters of water or broth each day. The reason for this is that when the body burns fat, it needs adequate water to flush out metabolic byproducts, and staying hydrated can help prevent dehydration. It’s also important to get enough dietary fiber, so eating more fresh vegetables can help stimulate intestinal motility and support regular bowel movements.

Meal replacements often lack enough protein to meet the body’s needs, and long-term consumption can lead to protein deficiency, which may reduce the body's ability to repair cells, cause loss of skin elasticity, and weaken the immune system. Therefore, nutritionists recommend that even when using meal replacements, you should ensure you're consuming a reasonable amount of protein-rich foods such as beans, dairy, eggs, and meats each day. Regular exercise is also very important; it helps increase calorie expenditure, maintains muscle strength, and improves overall energy levels.

5

Is Meal Replacement Weight Loss Effective? Try the Latest "Fat Loss Miracle" Instead!

Meal replacement diets may seem convenient and simple at first glance, but in reality, they often lead to weight rebound and come with many side effects. The Perfect Medical S6 Body Sculpting Treatment could be a truly convenient and simple weight loss solution, without the worries of side effects or weight rebound.

The S6 Body Sculpting Treatment uses highly effective non-invasive laser technology to target and disrupt the structure of fat cells in the body. This process helps to permanently reduce the number of fat cells and stimulates the lymphatic system to flush fat out of the body. As a result, weight is less likely to rebound, and the process is completely pain-free and non-invasive. The treatment can specifically target hard-to-reduce areas, such as the abdomen, thighs, and arms. After completing ten sessions, you can lose up to 10 pounds!